U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government, Department of Justice.

NCJRS Virtual Library

The Virtual Library houses over 235,000 criminal justice resources, including all known OJP works.
Click here to search the NCJRS Virtual Library

Playing the Race Card: Making Race Salient in Defence Opening and Closing Statements

NCJ Number
Legal and Criminological Psychology Volume: 15 Issue: 2 Dated: September 2010 Pages: 293-303
Donald O. Bucolo; Ellen S. Cohn
Date Published
September 2010
11 pages
Researchers have reported that making a Black defendant's race salient reduces White jurors' tendency to find Black defendants guilty (Sommers & Ellsworth, 2000). This study examined whether making race salient by including racially salient statements in the defence attorney's opening and closing statements (i.e., `playing the race card') reduced White jurors' racial bias against a Black defendant.
`Playing the race card' reduced White juror racial bias as White jurors' ratings of guilt for Black defendants were significantly lower when the defence attorney's statements included racially salient statements. White juror ratings of guilt for White defendants and Black defendants were not significantly different when race was not made salient. This effect was separate from jurors' level of prejudice (as measured by racial attitudes) as high prejudice participants were more likely than low prejudice participants to find the Black defendant guilty, independent of the race salience manipulation. The study indicated that an explicit attempt by a defence attorney to `play the race card' was a beneficial trial strategy a defence attorney could use to reduce White jurors' bias towards Black defendants. However, the beneficial effect of such a strategy may not reduce White jurors' bias towards Black defendants for all White jurors. The study obtained scores on racial attitudes for 151 White college students who participated in an experiment where defendant race (Black, White) and race salience (not salient, salient) were manipulated in a between-subjects design. Participants read one of four trial stimuli and completed dependent measures. References (Published Abstract)