NCJ Number
118853
Date Published
1989
Length
23 pages
Annotation
The purpose of this study was to determine whether there is a perceived problem in the Federal civil justice system regarding high transaction costs and undue delays and, if there is, to assess its perceived magnitude and probable causes.
Abstract
This study was conducted in 1988, of nearly 1,100 litigators and Federal trial judges concerning high transaction costs and undue delays associated with Federal civil litigation. This problem casts doubt on whether the civil justice system meets its basic objective of a "just, speedy and inexpensive" resolution of disputes. Transaction costs serve as a measure of the efficiency of the civil justice system, and indicate that a greater amount of the nation's resources are being expended in resolving civil disputes between parties. Also, this problem means a lower percentage of each dollar expended in the civil justice system is actually paid in compensation for damages. The major findings are that: (1) transaction costs are perceived to be a problem; (2) judges and lawyers agree that transaction costs lead to unequal justice; (3) discovery abuse is considered the most important cause of the problem; and (4) judges who inadequately manage their cases are also blamed for inflated costs. There is strong support for specific proposals designed to reduce discovery conflicts and to enhance judicial case management, and procedural improvements and reforms that would significantly reduce litigation costs. 48 tables and appendix.