NCJ Number
43572
Journal
Howard Journal of Penology and Crime Prevention Volume: 16 Issue: 1 Dated: (1977) Pages: 22-31
Date Published
1977
Length
10 pages
Annotation
WAYS OF RESPONDING MORE EFFECTIVELY TO THE NEEDS OF VICTIMS OF CRIME EXPLORED IN A DISCUSSION DRAWING ON EXPERIENCE IN GREAT BRITAIN AND ELSEWHERE.
Abstract
WHEN A CRIME IS COMMITTED, THE ACTION THAT FOLLOWS TRADITIONALLY IS FOCUSED ON THE OFFENDER. THE VICTIM HAS LITTLE PLACE IN THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM. THE CRIMINAL INJURIES COMPENSATION SCHEME, INTRODUCED IN GREAT BRITAIN IN 1964, OFFERS COMPENSATION TO PERSONS INJURED AS A RESULT OF VIOLENT CRIMES OR DURING ATTEMPTS TO ARREST OFFENDERS, TO PREVENT OFFENSES, OR TO HELP LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS. ALTHOUGH IT HAS LIMITATIONS, THE SCHEME IS AN EXAMPLE OF THE STATE'S ASSUMPTION OF RESPONSIBILITY OR COMPENSATING VICTIMS OF PHYSICAL VIOLENCE. IN ADDITION TO THE NATIONAL SCHEME, BRITAIN HAS LOCALIZED, VOLUNTEER-STAFFED VICTIM SUPPORT SCHEMES WHICH OFFER PRACTICAL ASSISTANCE AND MORAL SUPPORT, BUT NOT COMPENSATION, PRIMARILY TO VICTIMS OF PROPERTY OFFENSES. A COLUMBUS, OHIO, PROGRAM REFERS DISPUTES AND MINOR CRIMINAL ACTS TO AN INFORMAL HEARING, DURING WHICH THE VICTIM AND THE OFFENDER CAN AGREE TO A SOLUTION OUTSIDE OF COURT. THE MINNEAPOLIS RESTITUTION CENTER ARRANGES REPAYMENT CONTRACTS BETWEEN VICTIMS AND OFFENDERS. THE QUESTION OF WHETHER REPARATION IS ADEQUATE SANCTION IS ADDRESSED. BOTH THE RETRIBUTIVE AND THE DETERRENT ASPECTS OF PUNISHMENT ARE CONSIDERED, AND SHORTCOMINGS IN THE LOGIC OF TRADITIONAL APPROACHES TO PUNISHMENT ARE POINTED OUT. THE PROPOSAL THAT THE VICTIM BE HELPED BY THE OFFENDER OR BY THE COMMUNITY AND THAT THE OFFENDER BE REQUIRED TO MAKE AMENDS TO THE VICTIM OR TO THE COMMUNITY IS SAID TO BE ONE APPROACH TO DEMONSTRATING RESPECT FOR THE VICTIM'S FEELINGS AND OFFERING PRACTICAL HELP TO THE VICTIM WHILE TREATING THE OFFENDER IN A WAY THAT WILL DRAW HIM BACK INTO SOCIETY RATHER THAN INCREASE HIS ISOLATION.