The project focused on three general approaches for managing contextual information. One is the "case manager model," which separates functions in the laboratory between case managers and examiners, so managers can be fully informed about context, but forensic examiners are provided with only the information needed for the analytical tasks they are trained to perform. A second means of preventing contextual bias is "sequential unmasking" or "linear sequential unmasking." This procedure sequences the order of various forensic analytical tasks in order to ensure that forensic examiners make certain key analytical judgments before being exposed to potentially biasing information. The third method assessed for preventing contextual bias is "blind re-examination," in which key judgments of an initial non-blind examiner are replicated by a second examiner who has not been exposed to potentially biasing information. The research addressed the use of the three models in bloodstain pattern analysis and handwriting analysis. The ultimate goal of the research was the development of practical protocols for managing contextual information that could be implemented by bloodstain pattern analysts and handwriting analysts. This report indicates that the research findings it discusses will have a continuing role in future discussions of contextual bias in forensic science and will be a significant factor in decisions about how best to deal with the problem of contextual bias. The project's methodology is described. 15 references
Downloads
Similar Publications
- The Off-season of Dental Cementum Investigations. A Critical Appraisal of Season-of-death Prediction in Medico-legal Investigations
- Superhydrophobic Surface Modification of Polymer Microneedles Enables Fabrication of Multimodal Surface-Enhanced Raman Spectroscopy and Mass Spectrometry Substrates for Synthetic Drug Detection in Blood Plasma
- Police Use of Discretion in Encounters with People with Opioid Use Disorder: a Study of Illinois Police Officers